Yes Jordo, I here you. But between my 3 the other two are only slightly shorter in length (probably due to the different tail structure), and in terms of size and build I would say they are the same if not slightly bigger build. My guess is that they are the same age, having been selected from a group of five at "Pails" that all looked pretty much the same.
I still feel that the tail structure is a sign of their sex, the shorter tailed gidgee's, have wide based tails allowing for the hemipenes, which makes sense to me. The vent is "squared" in both of them as per Spongebob's post, allowing for the hemipenes to retract either side, which makes sense to me. Cujo's head structure appears smaller, base of tail more slender and vent rounder, which makes sense to me if she is female.
In terms of fat storage my 2 skink, suspect male has what I describe as a swollen tail, "very full" almost bulging kind of effect. And if it is fat its not being stored lengthwise but outwards bit like my waist wants to do when I have eaten too much.
And after looking at all this information we have crossed, looking at your 2 skink, he looks and feels like a little bull. Big head, big build, wide neck and short tail. And I got to say your 3 skink looks so much like Cujo.
What do you reckon? I still feel we have come a long way trying to sex these notorious egernia. My money's on mine being M,M,F and yours M,M,F,F.
It would be interesting to see, once you get a chance whether vents appear to confirm this theory.
Cheers
Uaru